So far this semester, I think Slaughterhouse Five has been my favorite book to read and discuss. One thing that came up multiple times throughout the discussion of this novel was whether it was successful in its goal of portraying war as accurately as possible, with no sugarcoating or glorification. I personally think that this novel did do a good job of that, especially of showing how big of an impact war can have on its veterans after the war. I think that Billy was a good 'poster-child' for a war veteran. He fought at a young age, and saw and experienced many horrors of war that stayed with him for life. His family around him treated him as if he was slowly going insane, but he felt that he was completely justified. Even we, the readers, debated over whether the events that Billy describes were true or just a figment of his imagination. Billy wasn't the type of war hero or role model archetype that anyone would envy or try to take after. He wasn't portrayed as ...
I love the idea that there are people involved and influential in the life of historical figures that we know and respect, but these "side characters" so to speak probably had unimaginable impacts on these people's lives. You really explore that in this story, and I also like that you go over time - they grow apart over the years but in the end can always rely on one another.
ReplyDeleteI like the unique perspective on Gandhi. I like the way you jump between key points in the timeline, but still maintain a continuous story throughout.
ReplyDeleteGreat job! I like that you showed us glimpses of the main character's interactions with Gandhi because they did a lot to show the character/personality of both of them. I also like that you did it from the perspective of someone that isn't in the spotlight because it's a unique perspective that isn't often seen.
ReplyDeleteI like that your story is about the non-famous part of Gandhi's life. Oftentimes, we only know these larger-than-life figures for their great actions not their ordinary lives before their great leadership, action, etc. I think people should write more of formative years of great people because great people are formed through their experiences and hardships.
ReplyDelete